改革与发展

高中阶段普职分流:误解、事实与愿景

  • 田志磊 ,
  • 薛懿 ,
  • 殷利
展开
  • 1. 北京大学中国教育财政科学研究所,北京 100871
    2. 江苏省太仓中等专业学校,苏州 215400

录用日期: 2024-10-10

  网络出版日期: 2025-01-18

基金资助

教育部2024年210教育管理与改革专项“人口新形势下教育高质量发展研究”(7121200031);习近平经济思想研究中心课题研究项目“畅通教育、科技、人才良性循环研究”(AZ2024009)。

版权

华东师范大学学报期刊社, 2025, 版权所有,未经授权,不得转载、摘编本刊文章,不得使用本刊的版式设计。

Academic and Vocational Streaming in High School Education: Misunderstandings, Facts and Visions

  • Zhilei Tian ,
  • Yi Xue ,
  • Li Yin
Expand
  • 1. China Institute for Education Finance Research, Peking University, Beijing 100871,China
    2. Taicang Secondary Vocational School, Suzhou 215400, China

Accepted date: 2024-10-10

  Online published: 2025-01-18

Copyright

, 2025, Copyright reserved © 2025.

摘要

近年来,由于大众对普职分流存在误解,教育焦虑在社会上不断产生和蔓延。在描述普职分流的事实和特征的基础上,本文重新审视了社会上对普职分流的批判。过去二十年,我国高中阶段普职比经历了过山车般的剧烈变化,但一直大于1∶1,当前高中阶段至少六成甚至三分之二的孩子在普通高中就读,个别省份这一比例已近八成。微观数据表明,家庭背景对普职分流重要但并非桎梏,学业成绩才是主导性因素;大城市家庭和多子女家庭在普职分流中面临更大的压力;男孩在普职分流中表现逊色于女孩。随后,本文围绕普职分流的主流批判提供了少数支持、多数相悖的证据。最后,基于对普职分流的实证分析,本文探讨了我国普职协调未来的可能路径。

本文引用格式

田志磊 , 薛懿 , 殷利 . 高中阶段普职分流:误解、事实与愿景[J]. 华东师范大学学报(教育科学版), 2025 , 43(2) : 105 -118 . DOI: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2025.02.009

Abstract

In recent years, due to widespread misunderstandings regarding the academic and vocational streaming, educational anxiety has continued to grow and spread in society. Based on a factual and characteristic description of the academic and vocational streaming, this article reexamines the societal criticisms of this streaming. Over the past two decades, the academic to vocational education ratio in China’s senior high school education has experienced roller-coaster-like fluctuations but has consistently remained greater than 1∶1. Currently, at least sixty to seventy percent of students attend regular high schools, with some provinces nearing eighty percent. Micro-level data reveals that while family background plays a significant role in the streaming, academic performance is the predominant factor. Families in major cities and those with multiple children face greater pressures within this streaming, and boys tend to underperform compared to girls. Subsequently, this article provides minority supportive and majority contradictory evidence surrounding mainstream criticisms of the academic and vocational streaming. Finally, grounded in empirical analysis of this streaming, the article explores potential pathways for future harmonization of academic and vocational education in China.

参考文献

奥戴德·盖勒. (2022). 人类之旅: 财富与不平等的起源(余江译). 北京: 中信出版集团.
  贺丹等. (2018). 2006~ 2016 年中国生育状况报告——基于 2017 年全国生育状况抽样调查数据分析. 人口研究, 42 (6), 35- 45.
  金鑫. (2016). 高中阶段普职分流的路径选择: 综合高中抑或普职分离?——基于PISA 2009的国际比较研究. 中国教育财政政策咨询报告(2010—2015), 420—434.
  梁国胜. (2019). “虚胖”只会毁掉中职教育前途. 中国青年报, 2011-05-30(011).
  田志磊, 赵晓堃, 张东辉. (2018). 改革开放四十年职业教育财政回顾与展望. 教育经济评论, 3 (6), 73- 91.
  王兵. (2016). 同胞结构、关键资源分配与教育分流——对初中毕业生的考察 (1978—2008). 教育学术月刊, (1), 51- 59.
  郑磊. (2013). 同胞性别结构、家庭内部资源分配与教育获得. 社会学研究, (5), 76- 103.
  Haegg, I. (2020). 2020 Journalism Senior Colloquium. MediaCentral. https://mediacentral.princeton.edu/media/Isabella+Haegg++2020+Journalism+Senior+Colloquium/1_2er6bxp2/.
文章导航

/