在一个多元价值并存的时代,价值冲突作为一种普遍的社会事实广泛地存在于社会生活诸领域,教育领域亦不例外。所谓价值冲突就是价值逻辑的冲突。价值逻辑的核心是作出特定价值判断的价值标识词。从价值的标识词出发,可以大致划分出两种不同的价值逻辑:评价逻辑和义务逻辑。有三种不同的价值冲突类型:评价逻辑之间的冲突;义务逻辑之间的冲突;评价逻辑与义务逻辑之间的冲突。在理论上,价值冲突要么以某一行为对某共同体会更好为依据来解决,要么通过强化某人的某种义务来解决。但在价值冲突的实际解决过程中,这种解决原则的运用有一个关键性的前提条件——行为者的"善良意志"和"责任感"。因此,对教育而言,培养和提升人的善良意志和责任感就成为应对和解决价值冲突的必由之路。
In an era of pluralism, the prevailing value conflict exists in every aspect of society, like in education. Value conflict refers to conflict in value logic, which includes valuation logic and obligation logic. Thus, value conflict can be divided into three types:valuation logics conflict, obligation logics conflict, and conflict between valuation logic and obligation logic. In theory, value conflict can be resolved either by following a better behavior model or by reinforcing an obligation law. However, value conflict resolution in practice needs a precondition, such as the "good will" and "sense of responsibility" of the actors. Therefore, to resolve the value conflict in education, it's essential to cultivate and promote the "good will" and "sense of responsibility" in education.
杜威.(2001).民主主义与教育(王承绪译).北京:人民教育出版社.
江畅.(1994).论价值冲突.人文杂志,(2),24-29.
康德.(2005).实践理性批判(韩水法译).北京,商务印书馆.
拉思斯.(2003).价值与教学(谭颂斌译).杭州:浙江教育出版社.
兰久富.(1999).社会转型与价值冲突.北京师范大学学报(社会科学版),(3),97-102.
塞森斯格.(1992).价值与义务——经验主义伦理学理论的基础(江畅译).北京:中国人民大学出版社.
万俊人.(2016).化敌为友如何可能.读书,(4),32-40.
王树声.(2008).课堂教学拒绝价值失衡.中国教育报.
杨发.(1995).论价值冲突.理论探索,(4),12-15.
余庆.(2015).儿童价值学习的现象学诠释.教育研究,(3),10-17.