我国高等职业教育迎来了一个历史性的发展机遇期。然而,高等职业教育的基本定位问题是我国高职发展一直以来的一个难点和痛点,特别是人们对“高等性”内涵的理解摇摆了几十年,这在很大程度上影响了高职的健康发展。准确理解新时代高等职业教育的“高等性”内涵,就成为高等职业教育继续向上向好发展的根本性问题。高等职业教育的“高等性”之惑具有很强的国别特殊性和“与生俱来”的矛盾冲突性,同时也是整个高等教育规模发展进程中必然出现的问题。高等职业教育“高等性”内涵的嬗变经历了谋求高等之名与“文化水平等同说”、廓清技术技能之别与“技术教育定位说”、弥补高技能人才缺口与“技能水平高超说”等阶段。面对新时代的新挑战,以往三种学说均未能与时俱进,无法被沿用。我们必须突破二元思维模式,建构基于类型教育的高等职业教育新的“高等性”内涵框架。在新的内涵框架下高等职业教育将呈现出全新样态。
Higher vocational education in China has ushered in a period of development opportunities. However, the basic positioning of higher vocational and technical education is still a pain point, especially for the definition of “higher trait”, which affects the growth of higher vocational and technical education to some extent. It’s essential to understand the connotation of “higher character”. The confusion of the connotation of “higher trait” is one of the inborn particularities in China, which is also accordant with the trend of the development of higher education. The connotation of “higher trait” has experienced three doctrines including “equal cultural level”,“technical education position” and “high skills”. In the present era, those three doctrines are all out of date. It is of importance to build up a new connotation of “higher trait” of higher vocational and technical education based on the notion of “Type Education”. Through the new connotation, the higher vocational and technical education will present a complete new pattern.
贺贤土. (2003). 高等职业教育"高"在哪里. 职业技术教育,(21),44-44
匡瑛, 石伟平. (2006). 高职人才培养目标的转换——从"技术应用型人才"到"高技能人才". 职业技术教育,27(22),10-11
匡瑛. (2006). 比较高等职业教育:发展与变革. 上海:上海教育出版社.
匡瑛. (2018). 智能化背景下"工匠精神"的时代意涵与培育路径. 教育发展研究,(1), 39-45.
孙毅颖. (2015). "高等性"和"职业性"二维视域下的高等职业教育质量评价. 中国职业技术教育,(12),75-79
邬大光. (2010). 大学分化的复杂性及其价值. 教育研究,(12),17-23
夏建国. (2010). 从三个国际教育协定看工程教育与技术教育的区别与联系. 中国高等教育,(2),39-41
徐国庆. (2011). 高职教育高等性的内涵及其文化分析. 中国高教研究,(10),68-70
严雪怡. (2009). 技术工人和技术员是不可相互替代的两类人才. 职教论坛,(34),48-50
杨九诠. (2018). "公平而有质量的教育"的双重结构及政策重心转移. 教育研究,39(11),44-51
张健. (2011). 防范高职教育的"职业性"异化. 职教论坛,(8),1-1
French, H. W. (1981). Engineering Technicians Some Problems of Nomenclature and Classification. Paris: United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization.
Trow, M. (2007). Reflections on the transition from elite to mass to universal access:Forms and phases of higher education in modern societies since WWII. In Forest, J.J.F., Altbach, P.G.(eds). International Handbook of Higher Education. Dordrecht:Springer.