In the past ten years, evidence-based educational research has been the academic pursuit, and it seems that only "evidence-based" educational research is a good study, a scientific study. All of a sudden, evidence-based education research featuring big data has become a fashion.In this paper, we argue that it's necessary to re-think the "evidence-based" educational research from the perspective of "cultural existentialism pedagogy". First, love is the basic way of human existence. Similarly, education research should also involve the human feelings and emotions of love. However, evidence-based educational research will become a "cold", "indifferent" and "stiff" study, lacking of human feelings and ultimate belief.Only "lively" education research is viable, highlighting life care and humanistic feelings. Therefore, from the perspective of cultural existentialism pedagogy, we advocate that the correlation between the researcher and the participant of study should have the process of encountering. Second, thinking is important to the existence of human. Evidence-based educational research tends to be obsessed with various data mining and accumulation,obsessed with various statistical models of computing and data modeling, analysis and discussion on management for all kinds of data. Therefore, in evidence-based educational research,there is a lack of true thinking, and a lack of studying on educational value rationality, thus leading to a lack of original ideas of "free thinking". Third, faith is the main mission of the existence of people. Not just the use of educational research data and the "evidence" to speak, it is more important to study hard to speak, speak with emotion, with his faith to speak, so faith problem is the problem of a lot of educational research. Without reverence, piety and persistent belief, it is difficult for researchers to truly love educational research, and it is difficult to find the law of education and the direction of development from the ever-changing data.
JIANG Yong
,
DAI Nai'en
. Limitation of Evidence-Based Educational Research:Perspective of Cultural Existentialism Pedagogy[J]. Journal of East China Normal University(Educational Sciences), 2017
, 35(3)
: 72
-79+170
.
DOI: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2017.03.008
坂田昌一.(1987).坂田昌一科学哲学论文集.北京:知识出版社.
曹志平,文祥.(2009).科学研究中信仰的合理性——爱因斯坦重要的科学哲学思想.河池学院学报,29(4), 1-5.
范会芳,蒋超.(2001).论社会学研究中的实证主义与反实证主义.齐齐哈尔大学学报(哲学社会科学版), (4), 38-41.
伽达默尔.(2004).真理与方法(洪汉鼎译).上海:上海译文出版社.
海德格尔.(2008).哲学:思的经验(1910-1976).陈春文译.北京:人民出版社.
洪谦.(1964).西方现代资产阶级哲学论著选集.北京:商务印书馆.
卡特赖特.(1979).现代社会心理学的历史透视.社会心理学季刊,42(1),87.
邝红军.(2009).教育是精神的成长:雅斯贝尔斯教育思想探析. 北京大学研究生学志,(3), 97-100.
李小方.(1988).从狄尔泰到韦伯:评反实证主义社会学.社会学研究,(1), 78-89.
刘安.(1984)."淮南鸿烈"百子全书(第五册). 杭州:浙江人民出版社.
马举魁、张和平.(2010).实证主义的现代性迷误——马尔库塞实证主义批判的现代性启示.西北师大学报(社会科学版),47(5), 103-109.
马俊领、刘卓红.(2008).论霍克海默对实证主义的批判——启蒙批判早期进路研究.广西社会科学,(11), 42-45.
马斯洛.(1987).动机与人格(许金声等译).北京:华夏出版社.
迈克尔·波兰尼.(2004).科学·信仰与社会(王靖华译)南京:南京大学出版社.
毛泽东.(2003).实践论·毛泽东:毛泽东选集(第1卷). 北京:人民出版社,275.
庞学铨.(2016).哲学必须面向生活世界.光明日报,2016-09-28(14).
王小溪.(2011).论教育科学研究的信仰危机.教育科学研究,(7), 9-11.
朱建平.(2014).确证逻辑:一种基于证据的认知逻辑.深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版),31(3),65-70.
Bonjour, L. (1976). The coherence theory of empirical knowledge. Philosophical Studies, (30), 281-312.
Davies, P. (2000). The relevance of systematic reviews to educational policy and practice. Oxford Review of Education, 26(3/4), 365-378.
Hammersley, M. (2001). Some questions about evidence-based practice in education. Paper presented at the symposium on "Evidence-based practice in education" at the Annual Conference of the British Educational Research Association, University of Leeds, England, September.
Hargreaves, D. (1996). Teaching as a Research-Based Profession: Possibilities and Prospects. London: Teacher Training Agency, 7-8.