举贤不避亲：内部人特征降低了学术论文的质量和影响力吗？——以中国大陆教育学术期刊发表的923901篇论文为例

李一杉, 刘金松

Relatives are not Avoided When Talents are Demanded: Does Insider Characteristics Reduce the Quality and Influence of Academic Papers? Examples from Mainland China

Yishan Li, Jinsong Liu

表 3 各“目录*时段”板块内部人稿件与外部人稿件的篇均下载量与引用量和占比

分样本 内/外指标 2001—2003 2004—2006 2007—2009 2010—2012 2013—2015 2016—2019 CSSCI来源 篇均下载 689.94/436.58 725.02/558.51 768.81/635.81 886.64/794.89 982.81/933.78 814.02/706.42 篇均引用 35.83/22.89 25.08/20.79 17.86/16.35 16.69/17.37 16.81/17.31 8.81/7.17 百分比% 9.39/90.61 9.29/90.71 8.17/91.83 9.31/90.69 8.43/91.57 7.58/92.42 CSSCI扩展 篇均下载 无 无 421.79/383.83 408.47/400.31 441.02/423.67 310.10/376.35 篇均引用 10.67/8.92 8.91/8.35 8.73/7.95 2.71/4.05 百分比% 8.38/91.62 6.24/93.76 5.69/94.31 6.05/93.95 北大核心 篇均下载 200.15/146.23 349.11/215.87 341.30/234.78 286.54/249.16 245.09/223.47 236.07/228.53 篇均引用 6.99/5.49 10.72/7.11 8.58/5.77 5.06/4.99 4.37/3.77 2.53/2.34 百分比% 5.68/94.32 4.05/95.95 2.86/97.14 3.55/96.45 3.91/96.09 3.95/96.05 普通期刊 篇均下载 147.28/121.47 206.91/187.23 221.83/203.03 198.64/181.27 158.35/136.75 136.37/155.06 篇均引用 5.20/4.32 6.22/5.80 4.89/4.25 3.99/3.51 2.78/2.37 1.67/1.63 百分比% 10.44/89.56 11.27/88.73 11.59/88.41 9.88/90.12 8.47/91.53 8.09/91.91