Two Opposing Views on the Essence of Education: An Analysis of Ivan Illich’s Criticism of John Dewey

  • Shiwan Tu
Expand
  • Faculty of Education, Henan Normal University, Xinxiang Henan 453007, China

Online published: 2024-11-22

Abstract

Ivan Illich criticized the mainstream of educational thought represented by John Dewey since the Enlightenment. Illich’s critique of Dewey took place in the “Long 1960s,” an era characterized by “counter-culture.” Ivan Illich’s ideas are closely related to “counter-culture”. Ivan Illich criticized John Dewey for ignoring, tolerating or fostering three hidden curricula of modern schooling: “control and compulsion” “escalation and progress” and “desire and expectation” Illich argued that these hidden curricula revealed the true nature of modern schooling. From this criticism, we could see their different views of the nature of education. Ivan Illich found that modern schooling is actually a myth-making ritual, It deviated from the essence of human education. It is the result of the institutionalization of values, and it also promotes the institutionalization of other values in the society, thus making the whole society become a “schooled society”. The institutionalization of values is at odds with the idea of freedom. John Dewey believed that the essence of human education should contain three dimensions: schooling centered on self-realization, schooling as political and ethical culture, and schooling as leisure. Different views on the essence of education are the products of different social ideals. Dewey’s social ideal is the ideal in society, and Illich’s social ideal is the ideal beyond society. Therefore, Dewey regards socialization as the essence of human education, while Illich regards enlightening the transcendence of human as the essence of education.

Cite this article

Shiwan Tu . Two Opposing Views on the Essence of Education: An Analysis of Ivan Illich’s Criticism of John Dewey[J]. Journal of East China Normal University(Educational Sciences), 2024 , 42(12) : 82 -98 . DOI: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2024.12.004

References

null 鲍德里亚. (2014). 消费社会(刘成富, 全志钢, 译). 南京: 南京大学出版社.
null 贝尔. (2018). 后工业社会的来临(高铦, 王宏周, 魏章玲, 译). 南昌: 江西人民出版社.
null 布拉西耶. (2023). 普罗米修斯主义及其批评者. 载于: 张一兵. 社会批判理论纪事(第15辑). 南京: 江苏人民出版社.
null 陈桂生. (2000). 教育原理. 上海: 华东师范大学出版社.
null 程天君. (2023). 中国教育社会学百年: 学科、学术与学问. 北京: 人民出版社.
null 德波. (2017). 景观社会(张新木, 译). 南京: 南京大学出版社.
null 董标. (2018). 教育哲学学科起源考辨——从低位关注论高位观照. 教育学报, 14 (03), 3- 20.
null 董标. (2022). 教育理论的知识基础是什么——教育认知革命“宣言”. 山西大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 45 (4), 92- 102.
null 杜威. (2001). 民主主义与教育(王承绪, 译). 北京: 人民教育出版社.
null 杜威. (2005). 我们怎样思维?经验与教育(姜文闵, 译). 北京: 人民教育出版社.
null 杜威. (2007). 评价理论(冯平, 余泽娜, 译). 上海: 上海译文出版社.
null 弗洛姆. (2015). 逃避自由(刘林海, 译). 上海: 上海译文出版社.
null 顾明远. (2016). 对教育本质的新认识. 基础教育论坛, (9), 59- 60.
null 顾明远. (2018). 再论教育本质和教育价值观——纪念改革开放40周年. 教育研究, (5), 4- 8.
null 胡克. (2001). 导言, 载于: 杜威. 民主主义与教育(王承绪, 译). 北京: 人民教育出版社.
null 怀特海. (2020). 教育的目的(张佳楠, 译). 北京: 教育科学出版社.
null 加卢佐. (2022). 制造消费者: 消费主义全球史(马雅, 译). 广州: 广东人民出版社.
null 康永久. (2016). 教育学原理五讲. 北京: 人民教育出版社.
null 李政涛. (2012). 中国社会发展的“教育尺度”与教育基础. 教育研究, (3), 4- 11.
null 刘小枫. (2022). 洛维特和他的老师海德格尔与欧洲虚无主义问题. 外国文学评论, (2), 5- 40.
null 马里坦. (2010). 教育在十字路口(高旭平, 译). 北京: 首都师范大学出版社.
null 梅耶. (2014). 前言. 载于: 鲍德里亚. 消费社会(刘成富, 全志钢, 译). 南京: 南京大学出版社.
null 矢野智司. (2014). 作为赠与者之先生的诞生与死亡——探寻教育起源的新视角. 湖南师范大学教育科学学报, 13 (1), 5- 12.
null 斯蒂格勒. (2023). 技术与时间(裴程, 等, 译). 南京: 译林出版社.
null 汤因比. (2010). 历史研究(郭小凌, 王皖强, 等, 译). 上海: 上海人民出版社.
null 滕大春. (2001). 杜威和他的《民主主义与教育》. 载于: 杜威. 民主主义与教育. (王承绪, 译). 北京: 人民教育出版社.
null 涂尔干. (2006). 教育思想的演进(李康, 译). 上海: 上海人民出版社.
null 陀斯妥耶夫斯基. (1981). 卡拉马佐夫兄弟(耿济之, 译). 北京: 人民文学出版社.
null 韦斯特. (2016). 美国人对哲学的逃避: 实用主义的谱系(董山民, 译). 南京: 南京大学出版社.
null 伊利奇. (1992). 非学校化社会(吴康宁, 译). 台北: 桂冠图书股份有限公司.
null 伊利奇. (2017). 去学校化社会(吴康宁, 译). 北京: 中国轻工业出版社.
null 张一兵. (2017). 代译序: 德波和他的《景观社会》. 载于: 德波, 居依. 景观社会(张新木, 译). 南京: 南京大学出版社.
null Bruno-Jofré, R. (2012). Ivan Illich’s Late Critique of Deschooling Society: “I was Largely Barking up the Wrong Tree”. Educational Theory, 62 (5), 573- 592.
null Bruno-Jofré, R. (2019). Localizing Dewey's notions of democracy and education: A journey across configurations in Latin America. Journal of the History of Ideas, 80 (3), 433- 453.
null Bruno-Jofré, R., and Zaldivar, J. I. (2022). Ivan Illich Fifty Years Later: Situating Deschooling Society in His Intellectual and Personal Journey. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
null Cayley, D. (2005). Introduction. In Illich, I. The rivers north of the future: The testament of Ivan Illich, as told to David Cayley. Toronto: House of Anansi Press Inc.
null Dewey, J. (1980). Learning to earn: The place of vocational education in a comprehensive scheme of public education. In Boydston, J. A. (ed.). The middle works of John Dewey, 1899-1924(vol. 10: 1916-1917). Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
null Dewey, J. (1982). Philosophy and democracy. In Boydston, J. A. (ed.). The middle works of John Dewey, 1899-1924(vol. 11: 1918-1919). Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
null Dewey, J. (1983a). Education as politics. In Boydston, Jo Ann (ed.). The middle works of John Dewey, 1899-1924 (vol. 13: 1921-1922). Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
null Dewey, J. (1983b). Social purposes in education. In Boydston, Jo Ann (ed.). The middle works of John Dewey, 1899-1924 (vol. 15: 1923-1924). Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
null Dewey, J. (1984). Individualism, old and new. In Boydston, Jo Ann (ed.). The later works of John Dewey, 1925-1953 (vol. 5: 1929-1930). Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
null Dewey, J. (1987). The challenge of democracy to education. In Boydston, Jo Ann (ed.). The later works of John Dewey, 1925-1953 (vol. 11: 1935-1937). Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
null Gintis, H. (1972). Toward a political economy of education: A radical critique of Ivan Illich’s Deschooling Society. Harvard Educational Review, 42 (1), 70- 96.
null Illich, I. (1971). Deschooling society. New York: Harper and Row.
null Illich, I. (1973a). After deschooling, what?. In Gartner, A., Greer, C., and Riessman, F. After deschooling, what?. New York: Harper & Row, Publishers.
null Illich, I. (1973b). Tools for conviviality. New York: Harper & Row.
null Illich, I. (1976). Medical nemesis: The expropriation of health. New York: Random House, Inc.
null Illich, I. (1978). The right to useful unemployment and its professional enemies. London: Marion Boyars Publishers Ltd.
null Illich, I. (1981). Shadow work. Boston: Marion Boyars Inc.
null Illich, I. (1988). The Educational enterprise in the Light of the Gospel. http://www.davidtinapple.com/illich/1988_Educational.html.
null Illich, I. (1996). Foreword. In Hern, M. (ed.). Deschooling our lives. Gabriola Island, Canada: New Society Publishers.
null Illich, I. (2005). The rivers north of the future: The testament of Ivan Illich, as told to David Cayley. Toronto: House of Anansi Press Inc.
null Lichtenstein, P. M. (1985). Radical liberalism and radical education: A synthesis and critical evaluation of Illich, Freire, and Dewey. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 44 (1), 39- 53.
null Marwick, A. (1998). The Sixties: Cultural revolution in Britain, France, Italy, and the United States, c. 1958-c. 1974. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Outlines

/