Focusing on quality and equityin admission, the paper takes Zhejiang Normal University as the research object and compares the performances of the students enrolled through "Trinity" Comprehensive Evaluation in the college entrance examination. The findings show that, despite the gaps between programs and grades, the performance of students enrolled through "Trinity" Evaluation as a whole is better than the reference group in terms of program identity, GPA, participation in the Party and student unions, as well as awards and honors. The data also reveal that "Trinity" Comprehensive Evaluation and enrollment are more favorable to urban students. The paper concludes that "Trinity" Comprehensive Evaluation and enrollment should be employed more cautiously and improved.
LI Yunxing
,
JIANG Hongyou
,
LU Chengjia
,
CHEN Tianyun
,
ZHANG Zhenliang
,
LOU Yingwei
,
LI Weijian
. Quality and Equity: A Case Study of the “Trinity” Evaluation and Enrollment in Higher Education Institutions[J]. Journal of East China Normal University(Educational Sciences), 2018
, 36(3)
: 41
-56+167
.
DOI: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2018.03.005
艾乐.(2014). 浙江省 "三位一体" 高校招生评价体系探析. 教育与考试, (3), 25-28.
鲍威.(2012). 高校自主招生制度实施成效分析:公平性与效率性的视角.教育发展研究, (19),1-7.
陈峰, 杨春燕, 曹红,等.(2016). 温州医科大学"三位一体"综合评价招生实证分析. 温州医科大学学报, 46(8),622-624.
冯成火.(2014). 浙江省 "三位一体" 招生模式改革的思考和探索.教育研究, 35(10),151-157.
观察者网.(2017). 美国印度裔男子申请医学院被拒,伪装成黑人之后被顺利录取. 取自:http://www.guancha.cn/america/2017_08_07_421673.shtml.
林上洪.(2015). 浙江高校自主招生的模式创新:"三位一体" 综合评价. 考试研究, (1), 28-33.
吕慈仙.(2015). 高校 "三位一体"综合评价招生模式的效率判据——基于学生群体学业表现的大数据分析.高等工程教育研究, (4),129-134.
盛兰芳.(2016). 浙江高校招生改革:探索现实版综合评价. 人民教育, (19),61-65.
夏青.(2016). 高校 "三位一体" 生源质量跟踪研究——以浙江理工大学为例. 浙江理工大学学报(社会科学版), 36(4),414-418.
阳光高考网.(2017).2017年三大专项计划帮农村学生上好大学. 取自:https://gaokao.chsi.com.cn/gkzt/sdzx2017.
浙江省教师教育质量监测中心.(2016). 浙江省师范生"三位一体"招生实施的调研报告(内部报告),2016年12月.