华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2016, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (3): 71-78.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2016.03.009

• 教育基本理论 • 上一篇    下一篇

论教育与人性的关系 ——保守主义人学视角的审视

吴全华   

  1. 华南师范大学教育科学学院
  • 出版日期:2016-08-20 发布日期:2016-07-26
  • 通讯作者: 吴全华
  • 作者简介:吴全华
  • 基金资助:

    国家社会科学基金“十二五”规划2013年度教育学一般课题——“人性的教育学意义及教育人性化的实践策略”(BAA13007)

Education and Human Nature: Perspective of Conservatism View of Humanity

WU Quan-Hua   

  1. School of Education Sciences, South China Normal University, Gouang Zhou 510631, China
  • Online:2016-08-20 Published:2016-07-26
  • Contact: WU Quan-Hua
  • About author:WU Quan-Hua

摘要:

本文旨在从保守主义人学思想出发,揭示教育与人性的关系。论文通过对相关文献中的保守主义人性论主张进行梳理、归纳,结果发现,保守主义有着丰富且独特的对教育具有重要启发意义的人性论主张,即人性是人的一种潜能,人的境况是决定人的行为善恶的条件;人性是不变的,人作为具体的社会存在是不完善的;人性人人平等,且现实表现是多样的;自由是人的本性的组成部分。依照保守主义的人学思想,论文对教育与人性的关系作理论推演的结论是,教育者不应将人的品行视为实体性的本性使然,并充分重视尊重和维护受教育者的人性尊严的意义;教育改变不了人性,更不能使人至善;我们不应将教育结果平等作为教育正义的直接和首要目标;教育应通过保守和创发自由,使人获得人性自由的成长。

关键词: 保守主义, 激进主义, 人性, 自由教育, 教育平等

Abstract:

From the perspective of conservative ideology of human, this paper aims to reveal the relationship between education and human. Although conservative ideology of human serves its political science, it is meaningful to examine education from the conservative angle, which contributes to refining the ideology of human and humanism position of education. Based on the review of related literatures about the proposition of conservative ideology of human, this paper argues that conservatism has abundant and unique propositions about human nature. In the view of conservatism, human nature is a potential ability. The moral issue of human nature is concrete, while goodness and evil is the concrete manifestation of the social realities. The relationship between human nature (as human potential) and the goodness and evil in human behavior is the same as a seed in different soil has different growth. Human being is a dignified existence, if a person lives without dignity, his or her life is not a real human life. Human nature is not only constant but also is the same everywhere. Human moral issue is no abstract, on the contrary it is concrete. As a concrete human morality, it is imperfect, and it is unlikely to be perfect. Human nature is the source of goodness and evil, the social system is not the source but is goodness or evil itself. Even if the social system is perfect, the tendency of evil in human nature also cannot be got rid of. Although human nature shows great uncertainty and difference, the possibility of human nature potential (goodness and evil) is constant, which makes human born imperfect, and is unlikely to achieve the highest goodness. Human nature is equal, and the actual performance of human nature is diverse. Immutable human nature is not only diverse but also natural. This natural diversity determines the social ability of different individuals and the difference between social roles. And the social ability of different individuals and the difference between social role leads to social inequality. Freedom is a part of human nature, but freedom is concrete and societal; it changes with the times and the environment. What’s more, freedom is based on the premise of order, which is real and meaningful. Although freedom cannot be separated from order, the value of freedom takes precedence over the value of order and authority. Without freedom of human nature, there would be no true virtue; without moral, there would be no human nature freedom. The conservative ideology of human nature has important educational implications. Based on the above analysis, this paper concludes that educators should not take the moral character and behavior of human being as a substantive nature but show much respect for the dignity of the educated. Only when the dignity of the educated is well respected can education be improved. The effect of education is limited, as it cannot change human nature and it should respect the imperfectness of human being. Education result equality should not be taken as a direct and primary objective of education justice. The orderly and virtuous freedom of human nature which liberal education aims to achieve is based on educational freedom. Without it there would be no liberal education. Education should enable the free growth of human nature by maintaining and creating freedom.

Key words: conservatism, human nature, liberal education, educational equality