华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2021, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (2): 40-49.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2021.02.004

• 基本理论与基本问题 • 上一篇    下一篇

论“用以致学”:指向素养发展的教学认识论

张良, 罗生全   

  1. 西南大学西南民族教育与心理研究中心,重庆 400715
  • 出版日期:2021-02-20 发布日期:2021-02-07
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金项目"化知识为素养的机理与教学实现策略研究"(CHA190268),西南大学人文社会科学后期资助项目(项目编号:SWU1909014)

On “Utilizing for Learning”:Teaching Epistemology for Competence Development

Liang Zhang, Shengquan Luo   

  1. Center for studies of Education and Psychology of Ethnic Minorities, Southwest University, Chongqing, China
  • Online:2021-02-20 Published:2021-02-07

摘要:

探究素养发展的教学认识论,旨在澄明知识与素养的关系及其转化的认识论原理与教学机制。素养作为道德性运用知识解决复杂问题的能力,这一学习结果基于知识并超越知识,诉求于学习者能够在复杂情境中开展道德性的知识迁移与运用。可见,实践性是素养的本质特征,内蕴知与行、理智与德性统一的认识论意义。这一本质特征诉求于教学认识论应处理好“学”与“用”的一体化关系。传统教学认识论虽然一贯倡导“学以致用”,但由于理性主义知识观的钳制,在处理知与行、“学”与“用”的关系问题上深陷先后论、工具论、机械论等二元论困境。二元论的症结不仅割裂了“学”与“用”内在的一体性,而且难以确保学习者所获学习结果的实践性。“用以致学”通过调整“学”与“用”的位次关系,旨在重估行动、实践的认识论意义,进而更好地促进“学以致用”。“用以致学”作为实践取向的教学认识论不仅勾勒出化知识为素养的教学机理,同时还体现了现代认识论研究实践转向的趋势、学习科学的最新进展以及中国文化内蕴的力行认识论传统等依据。

关键词: 素养, 知行关系, 实践认识论, 用以致学, 教学认识论

Abstract:

Inquiry into the teaching epistemology for competence development aims to clarify the relationship between knowledge and competence, and the epistemology principles and teaching mechanism of their transformation. Competence is the moral ability of using knowledge to solve complex problems, and this learning outcome is based on knowledge and beyond, and depends on the fact that learners could transfer and utilize knowledge morally in complex situation. The nature of competence is practice which implies the epistemological meaning of the unity of knowledge and action, intellect and morality. This implication demands that teaching epistemology should handle well with the integration between ‘learning’ and ‘utilizing’. Although traditional teaching epistemology consistently advocates ‘learning for utilizing’, clamped by the knowledge creed of firm belief in rationalism, it struggled with the dualism cruces including the time sequence view, instrumental theory and mechanism in dealing with the relationship between knowledge and action, ‘learning’ and ‘utilizing’. The crux of dualism not only split the inherent unity of ‘learning’ and ‘utilizing’, but made it difficult to ensure the practicality of learners’ learning outcomes. ‘Utilizing for learning’ adjusts the sequence between ‘learning’ and ‘utilizing’ and aims to re-evaluate the epistemology meaning of action and practice, so as to promote ‘learning for utilizing’. ‘Utilizing for learning’ as the practice-oriented teaching epistemology, not only outlines the teaching mechanism of turning knowledge into competence, but reflects the practical turn of modern and contemporary epistemology research, the newest development of learning science and the action-based epistemology tradition implied in Chinese culture.

Key words: competence, relationship between knowledge and action, practice-based epistemology, utilizing for learning, teaching epistemology