华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2019, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (6): 27-35.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2019.06.003

• 基本理论与基本问题 • 上一篇    下一篇

课堂空间中儿童形象的产生机制:权力抑或教育?

卜玉华1, 钟程2   

  1. 1. 华东师范大学教育学系, 上海 200062;
    2. 杭州英特外国语学校, 杭州 311122
  • 出版日期:2019-06-25 发布日期:2019-11-22
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金一般课题"我国学校生活中的儿童形象研究"(BHA160096)。

The Generating Mechanism of Children's Images in Classroom Space: Power or Education?

Bu Yuhua1, Zhong Cheng2   

  1. 1. Department of Education, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200062, China;
    2. Hangzhou Entel Foreign Language School, Hangzhou 311112, China
  • Online:2019-06-25 Published:2019-11-22

摘要: 本研究探讨的主要问题是能否通过开放课堂空间,赋权于学生以保证主动自觉学习的学生形象产生。为此,研究运用了以视频为线索的主体访谈法、田野研究和行动研究等研究方法,发现当教师权力过剩时,学生形象呈现出"课桌蜗居型""向日葵型"和"隐性反抗型"等多种形象,说明课堂教学有必要进一步消解教师权力,赋权于学生。然而,当教师下移权力,变更课堂空间结构之后,学生便呈现出"学习规则的变更人""不动脑筋的教学应声虫"和"不善合作的散兵游勇"等多种被动学习的形象,说明空间重构及权力下移并不是学生主动学习的充分条件。只有在教师变更课堂空间结构和下移权力,并加以教育引领之后,学生主动学习的形象才可敞现出来。这说明空间结构及权力并不是保证学生主动学习的充分条件,教师的价值引领是必要条件。

关键词: 课堂空间, 微观社会学, 微观权力, 儿童形象, 空间重构

Abstract: The research deals with whether lifting a restriction on classroom space and empowering students can ensure students' active and autonomous learning. It's conducted through video-clued subjects' interview, fieldwork and action research. The findings indicated that while teachers' power is surplus, students' images of "school desk dwelling", "sunflower" and "hidden resistance" will come out, which makes it imperative to dispel teachers' power. However, when teachers empower their students and change the classroom structure, the students present their images of passive learning, images like "changers of study rules", "mindless parrots of instruction" and "not-good-at-cooperating disbanded soldiers", which means that space structure and power are not the only factors restricting students' selfhood. Finally, when teachers further change classroom space structure, downshift power and apply educational guide, the students' new image of "idea-willingly-sharer" is unfolded. It's suggested that the mission of contemporary classroom teaching reform is not just deconstructing class space structure and empowering students but also placing higher requirements on teachers' value guidance. Only in this way can students' spiritual space be enriched and enhanced.

Key words: classroom space, micro-sociology, micro power, children's image, space reconstruction