华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2026, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (11): 108-120.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2026.11.009

• 高等教育 • 上一篇    

博士生校企联合培养的组织结构及其对培养成效的影响——基于不完全契约理论与组织嵌入理论的质性分析

魏丽娜1, 陈洪捷2   

  1. 1. 杭州师范大学 中国创新创业教育研究院,杭州 311121
    2. 宁波大学 教师教育学院,宁波 315211
  • 出版日期:2026-11-01 发布日期:2026-10-24
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学青年基金项目“校企联合培养对工科博士生创新能力的影响机制研究”(72304020)。

The Organizational Structure of University–Industry Joint Doctoral Training and Its Effects on Doctoral Training Outcomes:A Qualitative Study Based on Incomplete Contract Theory and Organizational Embeddedness Theory

Lina Wei1, Hongjie Chen2   

  1. 1. Institute of China Innovation and Entrepreneurship Education, Hangzhou Normal University, Hangzhou 311121, China
    2. The College of Teacher Education, Ningbo University, Ningbo 315211, China
  • Online:2026-11-01 Published:2026-10-24

摘要:

基于不完全契约理论与组织嵌入理论,以工程领域的博士生、企业管理者、校内导师与企业导师为访谈对象,采用深度访谈与质性文本分析方法,探讨博士生校企联合培养的组织结构及其作用机制。研究发现,当前博士生校企联合培养的结构类型主要呈现分工式协作结构、任务型合作结构、自组织融合结构,不同的组织结构背后隐喻不同的运行逻辑。进一步分析发现,当前博士生的校企联合培养普遍建立在不完全契约基础之上,契约难以穷尽培养目标与责任边界。不论何种类型与形式的联合培养,其成效并非单纯取决于组织结构,而是通过组织嵌入程度发挥作用。真实的培养需求是组织协同的起点,校企需求共识、信任机制以及资源与利益的共建共享,共同塑造了校企关系的嵌入深度,并由此影响校企联合培养的质量。基于上述发现,研究指出,应由形式化契约导向关系型契约,采用以需求为导向的产学研合作策略,推进校企双方的自组织协同,以提升校企联合培养的制度韧性与整体效能。

关键词: 博士生培养, 校企联合培养, 不完全契约, 组织嵌入

Abstract:

Drawing on incomplete contract theory and organizational embeddedness theory, this study takes doctoral students in engineering, enterprise managers, university supervisors, and enterprise mentors as interviewees, and employs in-depth interviews and qualitative text analysis to explore the organizational structures of university–industry joint doctoral training and their underlying mechanisms. The findings indicate that current university–industry joint doctoral training can be broadly categorized into three structural types: division-based collaborative structures, task-oriented cooperative structures, and self-organized integrative structures, each of which embodies a distinct underlying logic of operation. Further analysis reveals that joint doctoral training arrangements are generally grounded in incomplete contractual frameworks, within which training objectives and boundaries of responsibility cannot be fully specified ex ante. Regardless of the specific type or form of collaboration, training outcomes are not determined solely by organizational structure, but rather are mediated by the degree of organizational embeddedness. Authentic training needs constitute the starting point of organizational coordination, while shared demand alignment between universities and enterprises, trust-building mechanisms, and the joint construction and sharing of resources and interests collectively shape the depth of university–industry embeddedness, thereby influencing the quality of university–industry joint doctoral training. Based on these findings, the study argues for a shift from formal contractual arrangements toward relational contracting, emphasizing strengthened goal alignment and multi-actor collaborative governance to enhance the institutional resilience and overall effectiveness of joint doctoral training.

Key words: PhD students training, university–industry joint training, theory of incomplete contracts, organizational embeddedness theory