华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2026, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (11): 23-33.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2026.11.003

• 教育数智化转型 • 上一篇    下一篇

从竞争到协作:人工智能如何重塑教育逻辑

赵勇1, 仲若君2   

  1. 1. 美国堪萨斯大学教育与人文科学学院,美国堪萨斯州劳伦斯 66045
    2. 北京易知简教育科技有限公司,北京 100007
  • 出版日期:2026-11-01 发布日期:2026-10-24

From Competition to Collaboration: How Artificial Intelligence Reshapes the Logic of Education

Yong Zhao1, Ruojun Zhong2   

  1. 1. School of Education and Human Sciences, University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS 66045, USA
    2. YEE Education, Beijing 100007, China
  • Online:2026-11-01 Published:2026-10-24

摘要:

现代学校制度形成以来,“竞争-选拔”逐渐成为教育的主导组织逻辑。考试、排名、学历与分流不仅评价学习,也承担分配教育机会和社会位置的功能。这一逻辑之所以长期稳定,并非因为优绩主义天然正当,而是因为在知识、教育机会和社会位置相对稀缺、教育需要大规模协调的条件下,统一尺度上的比较与排序曾提供了一种可操作的组织方式。人工智能正在改变这些条件,并产生双重效应:在操作层面,依赖历史数据和既有指标的AI可能使分类与筛选更加持续、精细和不透明;在结构层面,生成式AI降低了获取知识、解释、反馈和认知工具的门槛,拓宽了能力形成与价值创造的路径。与此同时,高等教育扩张削弱了文凭的区分效力,AI进一步凸显仅凭考试和学历判断人才的局限。由此,教育正在用更先进的技术执行一种越来越不足以充当主导协调原则的制度逻辑。当标准化表现的区分作用下降、个体独特能力的重要性上升时,教育不仅要发展不同的能力组合,还需要在真实而复杂的问题中通过互补、协作和相互依存把差异转化为共同创造的价值。人类相互依存范式不是对竞争的简单否定,而是连接个体发展与共同创造的替代性教育组织原则。教育需要从主要“排序不同的人”转向“发展并组织不同的人”,通过个性化发展、真实问题行动、“人—人—AI”协作和支持成长的评价,使不同的人能够贡献所长、获得彼此支持并创造社会价值。

关键词: 人工智能时代的教育, 竞争—选拔, 教育优绩主义, 人才多样性, 人类相互依存, 教育范式变革

Abstract:

Since the emergence of modern schooling, competition and selection have become a dominant organizing logic of education. Examinations, rankings, credentials, and tracking not only assess learning but also allocate educational opportunities and social positions. This article argues that standardized comparison remained durable because it provided a scalable means of coordination under conditions of relative scarcity. Artificial intelligence is now changing those conditions in two directions. Operationally, AI systems built on historical data and existing indicators may make classification and selection more continuous, fine-grained, and opaque. Structurally, generative AI lowers barriers to accessing knowledge, explanations, feedback, and cognitive tools, broadening the pathways through which capabilities can be developed and used. Meanwhile, credential expansion weakens the differentiating power of degrees, while AI makes the limitations of judging talent primarily through tests and credentials more visible. Education may therefore be using increasingly advanced technologies to execute an institutional logic that is becoming less adequate as its dominant organizing principle. As standardized performance becomes less sufficient for distinguishing human capabilities and distinctive strengths gain importance, education must support diverse capability profiles and connect them through complementarity, collaboration, and interdependence in authentic and complex problems. The Human Interdependence Paradigm (HIP) is thus not a rejection of competition, but an alternative organizing principle linking individual development with collective value creation. Competition and selection will remain necessary in some contexts, but they should not define all learning goals or individual worth. Education should move from sorting different people on a common scale toward developing and organizing different people through personalized development, authentic problem-based action, human–human–AI collaboration, and assessment for growth and contribution.

Key words: education in the age of artificial intelligence, competition-selection, educational meritocracy, talent diversity, human interdependence, transformation of educational paradigm