华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2026, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (11): 47-63.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2026.11.005

• 课程与教学 • 上一篇    下一篇

“确定性的黄昏”:课程知识观的危机及转向

罗志敏, 张妍   

  1. 杭州师范大学中国创新创业教育研究院,杭州 311121
  • 出版日期:2026-11-01 发布日期:2026-10-24
  • 基金资助:
    浙江省哲学社会科学领军人才培育课题“科技强国背景下大学创新体系一体化构建研究”(25YJRC010ZD)。

The Twilight of Certainty: The Crisis and Shift in the Conception of Curriculum Knowledge

Zhimin Luo, Yan Zhang   

  1. China Innovation and Entrepreneurship Education Institute, Hangzhou Normal University, Hangzhou 311121, China
  • Online:2026-11-01 Published:2026-10-24

摘要:

人工智能技术的迅猛发展正深刻改变着教育生态,同时也暴露出传统课程知识观在时代转型中的滞后性及其带来的内在危机。以确定性为核心的课程知识观,不仅固化了“教科书思维”,强化对确定性、权威性知识的依赖,排斥生成性认知,还导致了课程研究中“沉思”传统的式微与研究重心的偏移,进而削弱了教育应有的价值与创造活力。随着人工智能在教育活动中的全面渗透,确定性的知识观进一步挤压沉思思维,加剧了知识获取的浅表化与教育价值的工具化倾向,也消解了其人文内核与育人本真。面对这一挑战,教育应转向融合性的知识观,即从追求确定性走向理解、接纳并善用不确定性,据此构建能融合明确知识、默会知识与暗知识的三维课程知识体系,以在开放性认知、具身性实践与人机协同中实现课程知识结构的动态重建。由此一来,大学教育尤须从知识观层面率先变革,超越单纯的技术应用与内容增补,致力于培养能够应对未知挑战、富于韧性与创造力的新一代人。

关键词: 课程知识, 确定性知识观, 融合性知识观, 课程建设, 大学教育

Abstract:

The rapid advance of artificial intelligence technologies is profoundly transforming the educational ecosystem, while simultaneously exposing the lag and inherent crisis of the traditional deterministic view of curriculum knowledge in this era of change. Centered on the pursuit of certainty, the conventional view of curriculum knowledge not only reinforces “textbook mentality”, intensifying reliance on definitive and authoritative knowledge while marginalizing generative cognition, but also leads to the decline of the “contemplative” tradition in curriculum studies and the displacement of its intellectual focus, thereby undermining the inherent value and creative vitality of education. With the pervasive integration of AI into education, this certainty-oriented epistemology further compresses contemplative thinking, intensifies the superficial acquisition of knowledge, and reinforces the instrumentalization of educational values, thereby eroding the humanistic core and educational purposes of schooling. In response to this challenge, education must transition toward an integrative epistemology—moving from the pursuit of certainty toward understanding, accepting, and skillfully employing uncertainty, and on that basis constructing a three-dimensional system of curriculum knowledge that integrates explicit knowledge, tacit knowledge, and dark knowledge. Through open cognition, embodied practice, and human-machine collaboration, this enables dynamic reconstruction of curriculum knowledge structures. Accordingly, higher education in particular needs to lead reform at the level of epistemology of knowledge, transcending mere technological application or content supplementation, dedicated instead to cultivating a new generation capable of facing unknown challenges, rich in resilience and creativity.

Key words: curriculum knowledge, deterministic view of knowledge, integrative view of knowledge, curriculum development, university education