华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2014, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (4): 1-7.

• 教育理论 •    下一篇

20世纪比较教育学者的历史方法论探析

彭虹斌   

  1. 华南师范大学公共管理学院,广州 510006
  • 出版日期:2014-12-20 发布日期:2015-01-06
  • 通讯作者: 彭虹斌
  • 作者简介:彭虹斌
  • 基金资助:

    教育部人文社科2014年规划基金项目“儒家文化背景下学校教育领导美德范畴与制度规约”(14YJA880055)2013年广东省研究生教育创新计划项目“儒家文化背景下研究生学术现状调查及学术规范研究”,编号:2013JGXM-MS19。

The Analysis of Historical Methodology of Comparative Education Scholar in the 20th Century

PENG Hong-Bin   

  1. Public Administration School, South China Normal University, Guangzhou 510006
  • Online:2014-12-20 Published:2015-01-06
  • Contact: PENG Hong-Bin
  • About author: PENG Hong-Bin

摘要: 比较教育学者萨德勒、康德尔、汉斯、施奈德与乌利希运用了历史法;其主要作品大致发表在20世纪初至60年代。从认识论的角度来看,萨德勒等人的历史法在认识论上分为目的论解释和因果性解释两种类型。在具体的历史法应用方面,主要运用的是历史比较分析、历史心理分析、历史宏观与微观分析,不过康德尔、汉斯和乌利希等人的历史法有一些不同。历史研究法有一定的合理之处,这些学者比较有效地分析了对象国的教育制度以及其独特性,并探讨了影响教育制度的因素。不足之处在于其历史法不够全面,没有将统计法、测量法等实证方法纳入进来。

关键词: 历史法, 方法论, 因果解释

Abstract: During the first half of 20th Century, till 1960s, the distinguished comparative education scholars such as Michael Sadler, Isaac Kandel, Nicholas Hans, Friedrich Schneider and Robert Ulich have published their major works which showing the importance of historical method. From the epistemological point of view, the historical methods that Sadler et al applied can be identified as two types: teleological explanation and casual explanation. The specific historical methods they adopted include historical comparative analysis, historical psychological analysis and historical macro and micro analysis . However the historical methods of Kandel, Hans, Ulrich et al are different. Historical research has some reasonable places. These scholars effectively have analyzed the country's education system as well as the peculiarity and explored the influencing factors of the specific education system. Deficiencies in their historical methods are lack of empirical methods such as statistical method and measurement, which make the historical method not as comprehensive as it should be.

Key words: historical method, methodology, causal explanation