华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2022, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (5): 118-129.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2022.05.012

• • 上一篇    

教育法典的体例结构:域外模式与中国方案

段斌斌   

  1. 华中科技大学教育科学研究院,武汉 430074
  • 接受日期:2022-02-25 出版日期:2022-05-01 发布日期:2022-04-27
  • 基金资助:
    教育部人文社会科学研究青年基金项目“中小学教育惩戒实施细则的科学制定与依法完善研究”(21YJC880016)

The Style Structure of Education Code: Extraterritorial Models and Chinese Solutions

Binbin Duan   

  1. School of Education, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China
  • Accepted:2022-02-25 Online:2022-05-01 Published:2022-04-27

摘要:

教育法典的体例结构不仅事关法典外在形式,也关乎内容取舍、条文布局、内在逻辑和体系安排,要体现完备性、逻辑性、体系性等要求。目前,域外教育法典的体例结构主要有三种模式及特点:松散模式虽有助于法典容纳海量内容,但编章之间缺乏逻辑关联,难以形成内在体系;并列模式通过增加平行分类维度克服了松散模式的散乱无序,但各维度之间仍欠缺内在关联,无从判断法典内容是否达到完备要求,也无从判断法典体例是否逻辑周延;类主轴模式虽保证了核心维度内的编章具有良好逻辑关联和层次结构,但主从维度之间仍缺乏系统衔接,一定程度上削弱了法典的逻辑性和体系性。我国教育法典应选择以教育类型作为“中心轴”的主轴模式,科学处理总则与分则、编与分编、章节与条款的逻辑关系,以教育主体统摄法典总则,以教育类型串联分则各编,以组织活动细化章节安排,以逻辑关系决定法条次序。

关键词: 教育法典, 体例结构, 教育法律, 教育立法

Abstract:

The style structure is not only related to the external form of the code, but also to the choice of the content, the layout of the provisions, the internal logic and the system arrangement. At present, there are three modes of the structure of foreign educational code: loose mode, parallel mode and quasi-main axis mode. Although the loose mode helps the code to accommodate a large number of contents, the lack of logical association between chapters makes it difficult to form an internal system. The parallel mode overcomes the disorder of the loose mode by adding the dimension of parallel classification, but there is still a lack of internal correlation between the dimensions, so it is impossible to judge whether the content of the code meets the requirement of completeness, or whether the style of the code is logical. Although the quasi-main axis mode ensures that the chapters within the core dimension have a good logical correlation and hierarchical structure, there is still a lack of systematic connection between the main and subordinate dimensions, which weakens the logic and system of the code to a certain extent. Based on the pros and cons of various models and the realistic foundation of my country’s educational legal system,the Education Code in China should choose a main axis model with the type of education as the axis, and scientifically handle the logical relationship between general rules and sub-rules, chapters and sub-clauses, chapters and clauses, in order to educate the main body. It controls the general rules of the Code, serializes the sub-paragraphs by education type, refines the chapter arrangement by organizing activities, and determines the order of the laws by logical relations.

Key words: education code, style structure, education law, education legislation