华东师范大学学报(教育科学版) ›› 2016, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (3): 61-70.doi: 10.16382/j.cnki.1000-5560.2016.03.008

• 教育基本理论 • 上一篇    下一篇

教育制度化的兴起及其逻辑

程亮   

  1. 华东师范大学基础教育改革与发展研究所,上海 200062
  • 出版日期:2016-08-20 发布日期:2016-07-26
  • 通讯作者: 程亮
  • 作者简介:程亮
  • 基金资助:

    上海市浦江人才计划C类“当代中国教育知识生产机制研究”(12PJC026)。

The Emergence of the Institutionalization of Pedagogics and Its Logic

CHENG Liang   

  1. Institute of Schooling Reform and Development, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200062,China
  • Online:2016-08-20 Published:2016-07-26
  • Contact: CHENG Liang
  • About author:CHENG Liang

摘要:

近年来,有关教育学作为一个学科的探究逐渐从认识论的层面转向社会学的层面,关注教育学的制度化过程。本文主要通过历史研究和比较分析,对教育学制度化在欧洲主要国家的兴起及其逻辑进行了描述和阐释。研究发现,教育学的制度化最初在德国的发端,一方面与当时中等教育阶段文法学校需要训练有素的教师有关,另一方面深受卢梭发现儿童所激发的泛爱教育运动的影响,同时也离不开现代大学提供的自由土壤。其后,教育学逐渐向丹麦、芬兰、瑞士、英国、法国等国扩展,形成了多元的制度化方式。在这些多元的方式背后,显示出教育学制度化的基本逻辑:它主要是根源于“实践的”甚至“政治的”需求,而不是出于理论或知识的旨趣;但它却在不同程度上塑造了教育学的知识传统,为教育学确立自身的“专业身份”提供了支撑。

关键词: 教育学, 制度化, 德国

Abstract:

Since the 1980s, scholars in China have been reflecting and reconstructing pedagogics as an intellectual discipline or field of study. In the framework of metatheory of education, many a researcher has been intellectually enthusiastic about the pedagogical issues such as pedagogics’ connection with other disciplines and its intertwining between past and present, West and China, knowledge and action. In recent years, a pedagogical shift has emerged from the epistemological dimension to the sociological one concerning the institutionalization of pedagogics, i.e. the establishment of faculty and development of courses and textbooks. This paper attempts to depict and interpret the emergence and logic of the institutionalization of pedagogics in some European countries using a historical and comparative method. It has been found that pedagogics was institutionalized in the eighteenth century in Germany, in the form of textbooks, chairs, seminars and faculties. This process sought to meet the demands for welltrained teachers in secondary grammar schools and the philanthropic movement sparked by Rousseau’s discovery of children, and was rooted in the intellectually free atmosphere of modern universities. Later, pedagogics displayed diverse institutionalization when spreading to Denmark, Finland, Switzerland, UK and France etc. In general, the institutionalization of pedagogics was to meet the practical or even political demands for training and educating teachers for the nationstates, rather than theoretical or knowledge interest. This institutionalization to a certain degree shaped the traditions of pedagogical knowledge, including the normative paradigm in Germany, “comprehensive social science”mode in France, and “foundations disciplines”mode in UK. And also the institutionalization served to construct pedagogics as a professional identity. With the accumulation of pedagogical knowledge and the multiplication of interdisciplinary interactions, pedagogics has produced the strong awareness of its own professional identity from its reliance on other disciplines in the early stage of institutionalization. Meanwhile, it has been struggling to legitimize itself as an academic discipline, not simply driven by practical demands.

Key words: pedagogics, institutionalization, Germany